Pearl River football is home to 28 NJCAA All-American selections in its history. Below is a list of all of those who have been honored.
| 2022 | Bryan Whitehead II | Defense - Second Team |
| 2010 | Melvin German | Offense - First Team |
| 2009 | Desmonod Ratliff | Offense - First Team |
| 2008 | Marcus Ball | Defense - First Team |
| 2008 | Hendrick Levertte | Defense - Honorable Mention |
| 2007 | Johnny Harper | Offense - Second Team |
| 2006 | Julius Gray | Offense - Second Team |
| 2006 | Demetrius Byrd | Offense - Second Team |
| 2005 | Jimmy Oliver | Offense - First Team |
| 2005 | Frank Harry | Defense - Honorable Mention |
| 2004 | Jimmy Oliver | Offense - First Team |
| 2004 | Larry Brackins | Offense - First Team |
| 2004 | Matthew Lott | Offense - First Team |
| 2004 | Levance Richmond | Defense - Second Team |
| 2003 | Larry Kendrick | Offense - Honorable Mention |
| 2003 | Larry Kendrick | Defense - Honorable Mention |
| 2001 | Charlie Reeve | Offense - First Team |
| 1996 | Cornelius Griffin | Defense - Honorable Mention |
| 1993 | Chris Ryan | Offense - Second Team |
| 1993 | Alfred Mack | Defense - Honorable Mention |
| 1992 | Craig Weaver | Offense - First Team |
| 1991 | Lateef Travis | Defense - Second Team |
| 1990 | Michael Toefield | Offense - Second Team |
| 1984 | Ricky Myers | Offense - Second Team |
| 1973 | J.W. Rawls | Offense - Second Team |
| 1973 | James Smith | Defense - Second Team |
| 1972 | Bill Wallace | Offense - Second Team |
| 1972 | Jack Gallagher | Defense - First Team |