Pearl River baseball is home to 21 NJCAA All-America selections
| 2025 | KK Clark | First Team |
| 2025 | Jacob Keys | Second Team |
| 2025 | Caston Thompson | Second Team |
| 2025 | Topher Jones | Third Team |
| 2025 | Jacob Johnson | Honorable Mention |
| 2024 | Hollis Porter | First Team |
| 2024 | Bryce Fowler | Second team |
| 2023 | Cooper Cooksey | Second Team |
| 2022 | Tate Parker | First Team/NJCAA Player of the Year |
| 2022 | Alex Perry | Third Team |
| 2021 | Tate Parker | First Team |
| 2021 | Landon Gartman | First Team/NJCAA Pitcher of the Year |
| 2021 | Graham Crawford | Third Team |
| 2019 | Wiley Cleland | Third Team |
| 2018 | Simon 'Meaux' Landry | Second Team |
| 2013 | Krisjon Wilkerson | Second Team |
| 2008 | Kyle Lindsey | First Team |
| 2005 | Craig Rodriguez | First Team |
| 2004 | Rhyne Hughes | First Team |
| 2003 | Jake Smith | Second Team |
| 1994 | Greg Guidry | First Team |